The eyeliners are very pretty, the multichrome doesn't look quite as dramatic as pictured, but the ones I've worn do have the multichrome effect in good lighting, and they are vivid, highly pigmented, and shimmery even in the worst lighting.
I'm very impressed with the quality! They have real staying power and do not wipe off or smudge easily once they're on, even with wet wipes it takes some work, so they're more on par with liquid waterproof liners I've used than other "mechanical pencil" type liners, in terms of how well they stay. I was very pleasantly surprised given the type and price!
Best of all, the customer service! I ordered 8 of these at once and was sent a duplicate of one color in place of another. I emailed the address on the packing slip and within SIX MINUTES I received an email with shipping info for the correct color.
Absolutely delighted with every aspect of my purchase of this product from HB Beauty Bar. Great product at a reasonable price (so you can afford to try several instead of only one!) that will stay all day.